She went to church, she was from the 'burbs
When she passed, all the heads turned
I'm from New York, rode a skateboard
And camped out on a corner
She and I didn't see eye to eye on politics and such
But when I tell you, oh, none of that mattered
When we got together, it was love

I saw her at her worst, still, I desired her
I learned to read her eyes and know when she would lie
I watched her start to hate me
'Til she could no longer take me, oh-oh-oh

She locked the door, but she left the key under the mat
Oh, and I've known this for a while
But I am still too afraid to act
Oh, and it's coming off the hinges
From the wall, it has detached
Oh, and I've known this for a while
But I am still too afraid to act

We moved into a shoebox out of school
And it felt like a honeymoon
She'd go to work while I made my songs
For a moment there, it was just us two

I saw her at her worst, still, I desired her
I learned to read her eyes and know when she would lie
I watched her start to hate me
'Til she could no longer take me, oh-oh-oh

She locked the door, but she left the key under the mat
Oh, and I've known this for a while
But I am still too afraid to act
Oh, and it's coming off the hinges
From the wall, it has detached
Oh, and I've known this for a while
But I am still too afraid to act

I was doing fine until it hit me on a random day in July
That you'll never be mine again in this lifetime
I was doing fine until it hit me on a random day in July
That I'll never be satisfied 'cause she will never be mine

She locked the door, but she left the key under the mat
Oh, and I've noticed for a while
But I am still too afraid to act
Oh, and it's got me on the edges of the water as attached
Oh, and I've noticed for a while
But I am still too afraid to act

Ooh-ooh-ooh-ooh
Oh-oh-oh-oh, oh-oh-oh
That's the album, man